How Do the First and Second Derivative Tests Classify Critical Points?
The First Derivative Test classifies a critical point by whether changes from positive to negative (a local max) or negative to positive (a local min). The Second Derivative Test instead checks the sign of there: positive means a local min, negative a local max, and zero means no information, requiring the First Derivative Test instead.
At a critical point where : First Derivative Test — if changes from to at , local max; from to , local min. Second Derivative Test — if , local min; if , local max; if , inconclusive.
Step-by-Step Method
- Find the critical points: solve , and also note any -values where is undefined.
- For the Second Derivative Test, find and evaluate it at each critical point — a nonzero result immediately classifies the point.
- If , the Second Derivative Test gives no information — switch to the First Derivative Test instead.
- For the First Derivative Test, check the sign of on both sides of the critical point, using a test value from each neighboring interval.
- Report the classification (local max, local min, or neither) based on whichever test actually resolves it, and double-check with the other test when both apply.
Worked Examples
- , zero at and .
- Second Derivative Test: . gives a local max at ; gives a local min at .
- Check with the First Derivative Test: testing at gives signs . At , changes to (local max, matches); at , changes to (local min, matches).
- , so — a critical point. , so — the Second Derivative Test gives no information here.
- Use the First Derivative Test instead: is negative for and positive for , so changes from to at : a local min.
- Confirm with direct inspection: for every real , so is in fact the ABSOLUTE minimum — a completely independent argument that needs no derivative test at all.
Common Mistakes on the AP Exam
- Using the Second Derivative Test when and either guessing or giving up, instead of switching to the First Derivative Test.
- Only checking where and missing a critical point where is undefined instead.
- Mixing up the direction for the First Derivative Test — positive-to-negative is a local MAX, not a min.
- Assuming every critical point must be a local max or min — some, like for , are neither.
- Forgetting to check the endpoints of a closed interval when asked for an ABSOLUTE max or min, not just local ones found from the derivative tests.
How This Appears on the AP Exam
- Both tests are constantly tested on AB and BC exams, in both multiple-choice and free-response questions.
- An FRQ typically wants the test named explicitly and the sign information justified (the actual test values or the sign of ), not just the final classification.
- A problem may require recognizing that the Second Derivative Test fails before correctly switching to the First Derivative Test — both skills are tested together.
Try a timed AP-style question on this topic — free.
Start FreeFrequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between the First and Second Derivative Tests?
The First Derivative Test looks at whether changes sign across a critical point. The Second Derivative Test instead checks the sign of directly at that point — it is often faster, but gives no answer when .
What do you do if the Second Derivative Test gives f''(c)=0?
Switch to the First Derivative Test — check the sign of on both sides of the critical point instead, since the Second Derivative Test cannot classify the point in that case.
Does every critical point have to be a local maximum or minimum?
No — a critical point can be neither, such as for , where does not change sign and the function is simply increasing through that point.
How do you find the critical points of a function?
Solve , and also check for any -values in the domain where is undefined — both types count as critical points.
Which test should I use on the AP exam, First or Second Derivative Test?
Either is acceptable when both apply — the Second Derivative Test is often quicker when is easy to compute, but the First Derivative Test is required whenever or is hard to find.
Related Topics
Keep going with timed tests & full mocks, study materials for every unit, DME Nova — your AI tutorthat won't make up an answer, and FRQ feedback scored against an exam-style rubric.
Start Free