CLT · Quantitative Reasoning · Number and Logic · 05.02

Mathematical Reasoning: Study Guide

Mathematical reasoning questions ask which statement MUST be true or MUST be false, which example is a counterexample, or what follows logically; some are set in the history of mathematics. Test each choice carefully and look for one counterexample to rule a statement out.

Sets and Logic

Logic questions ask what MUST be true, what COULD be true, or which example shows a statement is false. A single counterexample disproves an "always" statement; a statement and its contrapositive are equivalent. Venn diagrams organize overlapping sets.

Key formulas
Counterexample
Contrapositive
Converse (not equivalent)
Inverse (not equivalent)
Negation
Union of two sets
Union of three sets
Complement

Venn diagrams — two sets (neither)

Method. Total = A + B − both + neither.

Worked example
In a group of 149 students, 22 have a dog, 53 have a cat, and 15 do both. How many students do neither?
A60
B74
C89
D104
AnswerC — 89
Step-by-step
  1. Students in at least one group = 22 + 53 − 15 = 60 (the 15 who do both were counted twice).
  2. Neither = 149 − 60 = 89.
Quick check7 only the first + 38 only the second + 15 both + 89 neither = 149.
Common mistakes
  • A (60): gave the number in at least one group
  • B (74): did not subtract the students counted twice
  • D (104): subtracted the overlap twice

Venn diagrams — read a diagram

Method. Name each region first, then add only the regions the question asks for.

Worked example
The Venn diagram shows students in two clubs. How many students are in Soccer but not in Chess?
Figure for the worked example
A6
B10
C16
D32
AnswerB — 10
Step-by-step
  1. Regions: only Soccer = 10, both = 6, only Chess = 16, neither = 9.
  2. Only Soccer: 10.
Quick checkthe four regions add to 41, the whole class.
Common mistakes
  • A (6): gave the overlap
  • C (16): gave everyone in Soccer
  • D (32): gave everyone in at least one club

Set notation — operations

Method. ∩ = in both (AND); ∪ = in either (OR); A − B = in A only; A′ = not in A.

Worked example
Let U = {1, 2, 3, …, 20}, A = {2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 13}, and B = {3, 8, 9, 10, 11}. What is A − B (the elements of A that are not in B)?
A{3, 9, 11}
B{8, 10}
C{2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 11, 13}
D{2, 4, 6, 13}
AnswerD — {2, 4, 6, 13}
Step-by-step
  1. A − B keeps the elements of A and removes any that are in B.
  2. {2, 4, 6, 13}.
Quick checkCheck each element of the answer against the definition; nothing is missing or extra.
Common mistakes
  • A ({3, 9, 11}): gave B − A
  • B ({8, 10}): gave the intersection
  • C ({2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 11, 13}): included the elements only in B

Logic — converse, inverse and contrapositive

Method. Converse swaps; inverse negates; contrapositive swaps and negates.

Worked example
Which is the contrapositive of the statement “If a triangle is equilateral, then it is isosceles.”?
AIf a triangle is isosceles, then it is equilateral.
BIf a triangle is not equilateral, then it is not isosceles.
CIf a triangle is equilateral, then it is isosceles.
DIf a triangle is not isosceles, then it is not equilateral.
AnswerD — If a triangle is not isosceles, then it is not equilateral.
Step-by-step
  1. For “If P, then Q”: converse = if Q then P.
  2. Inverse = if not P then not Q.
  3. Contrapositive = if not Q then not P.
  4. Here P = “a triangle is equilateral” and Q = “a triangle is isosceles”.
  5. So the contrapositive is “If a triangle is not isosceles, then it is not equilateral”.
Quick checkonly the contrapositive always has the same truth value as the original statement.
Common mistakes
  • A (If a triangle is isosceles, then it is equilateral.): gave the converse
  • B (If a triangle is not equilateral, then it is not isosceles.): gave the inverse
  • C (If a triangle is equilateral, then it is isosceles.): repeated the original statement

Venn diagrams — three sets

Method. |A ∪ B ∪ C| = sum of singles − sum of pairs + triple.

Worked example
A survey of 70 students found: 30 like Math, 19 like Science, 33 like Art; 9 like Math and Science, 12 like Math and Art, 11 like Science and Art; and 6 like all three. How many students like none of the three?
A8
B14
C20
D56
AnswerB — 14
Step-by-step
  1. Inclusion–exclusion: at least one = 30 + 19 + 33 − 9 − 12 − 11 + 6 = 56.
  2. Students who like none = 70 − 56 = 14.
Quick checkCheck with regions: only Math = 15, only Science = 5, only Art = 16; all regions plus none add to 70.
Common mistakes
  • A (8): added back the students in all three twice
  • C (20): forgot to add back the students in all three
  • D (56): gave the number in at least one group

Logic — what must be true

Method. Draw the facts as arrows (taller → shorter); a statement must be true only if there is a path of arrows from the first person to the second.

Worked example
Ben is taller than Ana. Dev is taller than Ben. Dev is taller than Eli. Based only on these facts, which statement must be true?
AEli is taller than Ben.
BDev is taller than Ana.
CAna is taller than Eli.
DAna is taller than Dev.
AnswerB — Dev is taller than Ana.
Step-by-step
  1. Chain the facts from tallest to shortest.
  2. Every order that fits the facts has Dev above Ana.
  3. So “Dev is taller than Ana” must be true.
  4. The other statements are either possible but not certain, or impossible.
Quick checkthere is a chain of facts leading from Dev down to Ana.
Common mistakes
  • A (Eli is taller than Ben.): chose a statement that could be true but is not certain
  • C (Ana is taller than Eli.): chose a statement that could be true but is not certain
  • D (Ana is taller than Dev.): chose a statement that must be false

Number properties — divisibility reasoning

Method. Test the smallest multiples of 2 (n = 2, 4, 6); a choice that fails even once cannot be the answer.

Worked example
If n is a positive multiple of 2, which expression must be divisible by 4?
A4n
B + n
Cn + 1
Dn + 3
AnswerA — 4n
Step-by-step
  1. Write n = 2k.
  2. Then 4n = 4(2k), which always contains a factor of 4.
  3. Each other choice fails for some multiple of 2.
Quick checkwith n = 2, 4n = 8, which is divisible by 4.
Common mistakes
  • B ( + n): chose an expression that is not always divisible by 4 (it fails for n = 2)
  • C (n + 1): chose an expression that is not always divisible by 4 (it fails for n = 2)
  • D (n + 3): chose an expression that is not always divisible by 4 (it fails for n = 2)

Geometric Reasoning

Geometry questions on the CLT often ask what must be true from given facts. Use definitions and theorems step by step: parallel lines, congruent and similar triangles, properties of quadrilaterals, and the angle sums of polygons.

Key formulas
Angle sum of a polygon
Exterior angles
Congruence
Similarity
Parallelogram properties

Conditional statements

Method. Converse: swap. Inverse: negate. Contrapositive: swap and negate.

Worked example
What is the converse of the statement “If an angle is acute, then it measures less than 90°.”?
AIf an angle measures less than 90°, then it is acute.
BIf an angle is not acute, then it does not measure less than 90°.
CIf an angle does not measure less than 90°, then it is not acute.
DIf an angle is acute, then it measures less than 90°.
AnswerA — If an angle measures less than 90°, then it is acute.
Step-by-step
  1. The converse swaps the hypothesis and the conclusion.
  2. So the converse is “If an angle measures less than 90°, then it is acute.”.
Quick checkthe converse uses the parts in swapped order ✓.
Common mistakes
  • B (If an angle is not acute, then it does not measure less than 90°.): gave the inverse
  • C (If an angle does not measure less than 90°, then it is not acute.): gave the contrapositive
  • D (If an angle is acute, then it measures less than 90°.): repeated the original statement

Counterexamples

Method. Look for a value that meets the condition but breaks the conclusion.

Worked example
Which value of n is a counterexample to the claim “If n is a multiple of 6, then n is a multiple of 12.”?
A5
B41
C42
D63
AnswerC — 42
Step-by-step
  1. A counterexample makes the hypothesis true and the conclusion false.
  2. Test 42: it fits the condition of the claim but the conclusion fails.
  3. Each other choice either fails the condition or satisfies the conclusion.
  4. So 42 is the counterexample.
Quick check42 = 6 × 7 is a multiple of 6, but 42 ÷ 12 = 3.5, so 42 is not a multiple of 12.
Common mistakes
  • A (5): chose 5, which is not a multiple of 6, so it does not meet the condition and cannot be a counterexample
  • B (41): chose 41, which is not a multiple of 6, so it does not meet the condition and cannot be a counterexample
  • D (63): chose 63 = 9 × 7, which is odd and not a multiple of 6, so it does not meet the condition and cannot be a counterexample