HSPT · Mathematics · Quantitative Skills · 02.02

Geometric Comparison: Study Guide

The HSPT Quantitative Skills subtest has 52 questions in 30 minutes, with four answer choices, no calculator and no penalty for a wrong answer. Geometric comparison questions describe three figures, here named P, Q and R and described fully in words, and ask which statement about one measurement is true: area, perimeter, the fraction shaded, or the size of an angle. Exactly one of the four statements is true. This topic covers how to read these questions, shortcuts that replace long arithmetic, areas and perimeters of polygons, and circles, shaded parts and angles.

How Geometric Comparisons Work

First decide which measurement the question compares: area, perimeter, shaded fraction or angle size. Find that measurement for each of P, Q and R, write the three values down, and test every statement against them. Area and perimeter are the pair most often confused, so check which one the question asks for.

Key formulas
Area of a rectangleA=l×wA = l \times w
Area of a squareA=s2A = s^{2}
Perimeter of a rectangleP=2l+2wP = 2l + 2w
Perimeter of a squareP=4sP = 4s
Area of a triangleA=12bhA = \tfrac{1}{2}bh
Volume of a boxV=l×w×h,cube: V=s3V = l \times w \times h,\quad \text{cube: } V = s^{3}

Compare rectangle areas

Method. Decide what is being compared, find it for each figure, then test every statement.

Worked example. Square P has side 5, rectangle Q is 4 by 6, and rectangle R is 3 by 8. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) P and Q are equal
  • (B) P is less than R
  • (C) P, Q and R are equal
  • (D) Q and R are equal
AnswerD — Q and R are equal
Step-by-step
  1. P: 5 × 5 = 25.
  2. Q: 4 × 6 = 24.
  3. R: 3 × 8 = 24.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: Q and R are equal.
Fast methodArea is length × width; for a square it is side × side.
Quick checkCheck: P = 25, Q = 24, R = 24; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (P and Q are equal): compared perimeters instead of areas: P and Q both have perimeter 20
  • B (P is less than R): took the area of square P as 5 × 4 = 20, which is its perimeter
  • C (P, Q and R are equal): saw that Q and R are equal and assumed P was the same without working it out

Compare perimeters

Method. Add every side of each figure, then test the statements.

Worked example. Square P has side 6, equilateral triangle Q has side 8, and rectangle R is 7 by 5. Which is true of their perimeters?

  • (A) Q is less than P
  • (B) P, Q and R are equal
  • (C) R is less than P
  • (D) R is greater than Q
AnswerB — P, Q and R are equal
Step-by-step
  1. P: 4 × 6 = 24.
  2. Q: 3 × 8 = 24.
  3. R: 2 × 7 + 2 × 5 = 14 + 10 = 24.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: P, Q and R are equal.
Fast methodPerimeter is the distance all the way round: add every side.
Quick checkCheck: P = 24, Q = 24, R = 24; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (Q is less than P): counted only two sides of the triangle: 8 + 8 = 16
  • C (R is less than P): added only two sides of the rectangle: 7 + 5 = 12
  • D (R is greater than Q): used the area of R, 35, instead of its perimeter

Triangle against rectangles

Method. Use the right area rule for each shape before comparing.

Worked example. Triangle P has base 10 and height 6, rectangle Q is 5 by 6, and square R has side 5. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) R is less than P
  • (B) P is greater than Q
  • (C) Q is less than R
  • (D) P is less than R
AnswerA — R is less than P
Step-by-step
  1. P: 1/2 × 10 × 6 = 30.
  2. Q: 5 × 6 = 30.
  3. R: 5 × 5 = 25.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: R is less than P.
Fast methodA triangle is half of the rectangle with the same base and height.
Quick checkCheck: P = 30, Q = 30, R = 25; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • B (P is greater than Q): forgot to halve for the triangle: 10 × 6 = 60
  • C (Q is less than R): halved the rectangle as if it were a triangle, getting 15
  • D (P is less than R): halved both the base and the height of P: 5 × 3 = 15

Reason Instead of Computing

Many comparisons can be settled without long arithmetic. Triangles with the same base and height have equal areas whatever their shape, and each is half of the rectangle with that base and height. Scaling every length by k multiplies the perimeter by k but the area by k2^{2}. A square notch cut from a corner leaves the perimeter unchanged, and equal perimeters do not mean equal areas.

Key formulas
Scaling every length by kperimeter×k,area×k2\text{perimeter} \times k,\quad \text{area} \times k^{2}
Same base and heighttriangles have equal areas\text{triangles have equal areas}
Triangle and rectangleA△=12Arectangle (same base and height)A_{\triangle} = \tfrac{1}{2}A_{\text{rectangle}} \text{ (same base and height)}
Corner notchthe perimeter is unchanged\text{the perimeter is unchanged}
Fixed perimeterthe closer to a square, the larger the area\text{the closer to a square, the larger the area}

Scaled squares

Method. Use the scale factor squared for areas.

Worked example. Square P has side 4, square Q has side 8, and square R has side 2. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) Q is twice P
  • (B) Q is four times P
  • (C) R is greater than P
  • (D) P, Q and R are equal
AnswerB — Q is four times P
Step-by-step
  1. P: 4 × 4 = 16.
  2. Q: 8 × 8 = 64.
  3. R: 2 × 2 = 4.
  4. Doubling the side multiplies the area by 2 × 2 = 4, so Q is four times P and P is four times R.
  5. Only one statement fits these values: Q is four times P.
Fast methodScale factor 2 on the sides means scale factor 4 on the area.
Quick checkCheck: P = 16, Q = 64, R = 4; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (Q is twice P): thought doubling the side doubles the area
  • C (R is greater than P): read "greater than" as "less than", turning the statement around
  • D (P, Q and R are equal): thought squares all have the same area because they are the same shape

Same base and height

Method. Look for equal bases and heights before computing.

Worked example. Triangle P has base 8 and height 5. Triangle Q also has base 8 and height 5, but it leans so that its top point is beyond the end of its base. Rectangle R is 8 by 5. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) P plus Q equals R
  • (B) Q is greater than P
  • (C) P and R are equal
  • (D) R is four times P
AnswerA — P plus Q equals R
Step-by-step
  1. P: 1/2 × 8 × 5 = 20.
  2. Q: the same base and height give the same area, 20.
  3. R: 8 × 5 = 40.
  4. So P and Q together make 40, the area of R.
  5. Only one statement fits these values: P plus Q equals R.
Fast methodTriangles with the same base and height have equal areas, each half of the matching rectangle.
Quick checkCheck: P = 20, Q = 20, R = 40; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • B (Q is greater than P): thought the leaning triangle is bigger because its slanted side is longer
  • C (P and R are equal): forgot to halve for triangle P: 8 × 5 = 40
  • D (R is four times P): halved both the base and the height of P: 4 × 2.5 = 10

Perimeter with a corner notch

Method. Track which edges a cut removes and which it adds.

Worked example. Rectangle P is 10 by 4. Square Q has side 7. Figure R is a 10 by 4 rectangle with a 2 by 2 square cut out of one corner. Which is true of their perimeters?

  • (A) R is less than P
  • (B) Q is greater than P
  • (C) P, Q and R are equal
  • (D) R is greater than P
AnswerC — P, Q and R are equal
Step-by-step
  1. P: 2 × 10 + 2 × 4 = 20 + 8 = 28.
  2. Q: 4 × 7 = 28.
  3. R: the cut removes two edges of 2 from the outside but adds two new edges of 2 inside the corner, so the perimeter stays 28.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: P, Q and R are equal.
Fast methodA corner notch moves two edges inward without changing their total length.
Quick checkCheck: P = 28, Q = 28, R = 28; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (R is less than P): thought cutting out a corner must make the perimeter smaller
  • B (Q is greater than P): compared areas instead: Q is 49 and P is 40
  • D (R is greater than P): added the two new edges without removing the two cut away: 28 + 4 = 32

Areas and Perimeters of Polygons

Use the height, the distance straight across at right angles to the base, never a slanted side. A trapezoid uses the average of its two parallel sides. For a figure with a piece cut out, take the whole area and subtract the piece. When a square is given by its area, take the square root to find its side.

Key formulas
ParallelogramA=bhA = bh
TrapezoidA=12(a+b)hA = \tfrac{1}{2}(a + b)h
Square from its areas=As = \sqrt{A}
Equilateral triangleP=3sP = 3s
Figure with a piece cut outA=Awhole−AremovedA = A_{\text{whole}} - A_{\text{removed}}
Polygon anglesinterior sum (n−2)×180∘,exterior sum 360∘,regular: each=sumn\text{interior sum } (n-2)\times180^\circ,\quad \text{exterior sum } 360^\circ,\quad \text{regular: each} = \dfrac{\text{sum}}{n}

Right triangle area

Method. Use the right area rule for each shape.

Worked example. Rectangle P is 9 by 2, square Q has side 4, and right triangle R has legs 6 and 6. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) R is greater than P
  • (B) Q is greater than R
  • (C) P is less than Q
  • (D) P and R are equal
AnswerD — P and R are equal
Step-by-step
  1. P: 9 × 2 = 18.
  2. Q: 4 × 4 = 16.
  3. R: the legs are the base and height, so 1/2 × 6 × 6 = 18.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: P and R are equal.
Fast methodThe two legs of a right triangle are its base and height.
Quick checkCheck: P = 18, Q = 16, R = 18; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (R is greater than P): forgot to halve for the triangle: 6 × 6 = 36
  • B (Q is greater than R): halved both legs of R: 3 × 3 = 9
  • C (P is less than Q): added the sides of P instead of multiplying: 9 + 2 = 11

Square given by its area

Method. Find any missing side before adding the sides.

Worked example. Rectangle P is 12 by 3, square Q has area 64, and equilateral triangle R has side 11. Which is true of their perimeters?

  • (A) Q is greater than R
  • (B) P is greater than R
  • (C) Q is less than P
  • (D) R is greater than Q, and Q is greater than P
AnswerD — R is greater than Q, and Q is greater than P
Step-by-step
  1. P: 2 × 12 + 2 × 3 = 24 + 6 = 30.
  2. Q: the side is √64 = 8, so the perimeter is 4 × 8 = 32.
  3. R: 3 × 11 = 33.
  4. In order: R 33, Q 32, P 30.
  5. Only one statement fits these values: R is greater than Q, and Q is greater than P.
Fast methodGet the side of a square from its area with a square root first.
Quick checkCheck: P = 30, Q = 32, R = 33; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (Q is greater than R): used the area 64 as the perimeter of Q
  • B (P is greater than R): counted only two sides of R: 11 + 11 = 22
  • C (Q is less than P): divided the area by 4 and used 64 ÷ 4 = 16 as the perimeter of Q

Parallelogram, trapezoid and triangle

Method. Pick the right formula and the right height for each shape.

Worked example. Parallelogram P has base 9, slanted sides 5 and height 4. Trapezoid Q has parallel sides 5 and 7 and height 6. Triangle R has base 12 and height 6. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) Q is greater than P
  • (B) P, Q and R are equal
  • (C) R is greater than P
  • (D) P is greater than R
AnswerB — P, Q and R are equal
Step-by-step
  1. P: base × height = 9 × 4 = 36.
  2. Q: 1/2 × (5 + 7) × 6 = 1/2 × 12 × 6 = 36.
  3. R: 1/2 × 12 × 6 = 36.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: P, Q and R are equal.
Fast methodUse the height, never the slanted side; the trapezoid is the triangle R with the same 12 and 6.
Quick checkCheck: P = 36, Q = 36, R = 36; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (Q is greater than P): forgot to halve for the trapezoid: (5 + 7) × 6 = 72
  • C (R is greater than P): forgot to halve for the triangle: 12 × 6 = 72
  • D (P is greater than R): used the slanted side instead of the height for P: 9 × 5 = 45

Circles, Shaded Parts and Angles

Keep π as a symbol when every value has it, and compare the numbers in front; when comparing with a plain number, use π ≈ 3.14. A shaded fraction compares the shaded part with its own figure, so simplify it before comparing. Key angle facts: a right angle is 90°, a straight angle 180°, and the angles of a triangle add to 180°.

Key formulas
Area of a circleA=πr2A = \pi r^{2}
CircumferenceC=2πr=πdC = 2\pi r = \pi d
The size of π3.14<π<3.153.14 < \pi < 3.15
Shaded fractionshaded areawhole area\dfrac{\text{shaded area}}{\text{whole area}}
Angle sumstriangle 180∘, straight line 180∘, full turn 360∘\text{triangle } 180^\circ,\ \text{straight line } 180^\circ,\ \text{full turn } 360^\circ
Complement and supplementx+y=90∘ (complementary),x+y=180∘ (supplementary)x + y = 90^\circ \text{ (complementary)},\quad x + y = 180^\circ \text{ (supplementary)}

Circle areas with π

Method. Square the radius, keep π, and compare the numbers in front.

Worked example. Circle P has radius 3, circle Q has diameter 6, and circle R has radius 6. Which is true of their areas?

  • (A) R is four times P
  • (B) R is twice P
  • (C) Q is greater than P
  • (D) P is greater than R
AnswerA — R is four times P
Step-by-step
  1. P: π × 32^{2} = 9π.
  2. Q: the radius is 6 ÷ 2 = 3, so the area is also 9π.
  3. R: π × 62^{2} = 36π.
  4. Since 36 = 4 × 9, R is four times P.
  5. Only one statement fits these values: R is four times P.
Fast methodKeep π as a symbol and compare 9, 9 and 36.
Quick checkCheck: P = 9π, Q = 9π, R = 36π; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • B (R is twice P): thought doubling the radius doubles the area
  • C (Q is greater than P): used the diameter 6 as the radius of Q
  • D (P is greater than R): read "greater than" as "less than", turning the statement around

Shaded fractions

Method. Write each shaded part as a fraction of its own figure and simplify.

Worked example. Square P is split into 4 equal parts with 1 part shaded. Rectangle Q is split into 8 equal parts with 2 parts shaded. Circle R is split into 6 equal slices with 2 slices shaded. Which is true of the fraction of each figure that is shaded?

  • (A) Q is greater than P
  • (B) Q and R are equal
  • (C) R is greater than P
  • (D) P is greater than R
AnswerC — R is greater than P
Step-by-step
  1. P: 1/4 is shaded.
  2. Q: 2/8 = 1/4 is shaded.
  3. R: 2/6 = 1/3 is shaded.
  4. Thirds are bigger than fourths, so R has the largest shaded fraction.
  5. Only one statement fits these values: R is greater than P.
Fast methodSimplify each shaded fraction before comparing.
Quick checkCheck: P = 1/4, Q = 1/4, R = 1/3; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (Q is greater than P): compared the number of shaded parts: 2 is more than 1
  • B (Q and R are equal): compared only the number of shaded parts: Q and R both have 2
  • D (P is greater than R): thought 1/4 is more than 1/3 because 4 is more than 3

Angle facts

Method. Use the angle facts to find each angle, then compare.

Worked example. Angle P is one angle of an equilateral triangle. Angle Q is the angle between a side of a square and its diagonal. Angle R is the third angle of a triangle whose other two angles are 50° and 70°. Which is true of the sizes of the angles?

  • (A) R is greater than P
  • (B) Q is greater than P
  • (C) Q is less than R
  • (D) R is less than Q
AnswerC — Q is less than R
Step-by-step
  1. P: the three equal angles share 180°, so each is 180 ÷ 3 = 60°.
  2. Q: the diagonal cuts the 90° corner in half: 90 ÷ 2 = 45°.
  3. R: 180 − 50 − 70 = 60°.
  4. Only one statement fits these values: Q is less than R.
Fast methodAngles in a triangle add to 180°, and a diagonal halves each right angle of a square.
Quick checkCheck: P = 60°, Q = 45°, R = 60°; each of the other three statements fails for these values ✓.
Why the other choices are wrong
  • A (R is greater than P): used 360° for the triangle: 360 − 50 − 70 = 240
  • B (Q is greater than P): used the whole corner of the square, 90°
  • D (R is less than Q): read "less than" as "greater than", turning the statement around